ABOUT
THE FILM 

Intermarriage in the Florida Panhandle

A Story of Power, Fear, and Survival

​

Long before Florida became part of the United States, the Panhandle was home to thriving Native nations; the Apalachee, Chatot, and Pensacola among them. By the 1700s, however, war, disease, and displacement had drastically reduced these populations. Into this vacuum came waves of Muscogee-speaking people from Georgia and Alabama. The British, either unable or unwilling to pronounce “Muscogee,” simply called them the Creek, since many of their towns were built along river systems. These Muskogee migrants, along with smaller groups like the Yuchi, formed the foundation of what would later be known as the Seminoles in Florida.

​

From the beginning, intermarriage played a central role in the Panhandle’s frontier society. During the Spanish mission era, unions between Spaniards and Native women were sometimes encouraged to strengthen alliances and promote conversion. After the decline of the missions, intermarriage continued under British influence, as Scots-Irish traders ventured into Muskogee and Seminole towns seeking access to deer hides, trade networks, and political influence. Marriage into Native clans provided protection and legitimacy. For Native communities, these unions created trusted trade partners and children who could navigate both Native and European worlds. The descendants of these marriages, like the McQueens and Weatherfords, often rose to positions of leadership.

​

At the same time, Spain, which ruled Florida for much of the 16th through early 19th centuries, embraced a policy of inclusion. Spanish officials encouraged intermarriage and welcomed African runaways from the British colonies, provided they converted to Catholicism and pledged loyalty to the Crown. For Spain, this was not merely benevolence: it was strategic. Every runaway who joined the Seminoles or lived in a free Black town like Fort Mose weakened the English slave economy and strengthened Spain’s defensive frontier. Over time, the Seminoles and these free black allies, often bound by marriage and kinship, formed the Black Seminole communities which are a living testament to Afro-Indigenous alliance.

​

But what Spain viewed as strength, the United States saw as a threat. By the early 1800s, U.S. slaveholders in Georgia and Alabama feared the Florida frontier. To them, it was a dangerous melting pot: Muskogee (Creek) communities, free Black villages, and intermarried families of mixed Native, African, and European descent all living beyond American control. The fear of racial mixing, combined with the reality of enslaved people escaping south, became a central justification for Andrew Jackson’s invasion of Spanish Florida during the First Seminole War (1817–1818).

​

When the U.S. formally acquired Florida in 1821, everything changed for these intermarried families. What Spain had tolerated, even encouraged, the U.S. tried to dismantle. Scots-Irish men who had once been respected traders were now regarded with suspicion if they remained with Native wives. Children of mixed marriages, once valued as cultural intermediaries, found themselves “too Indian” to be white, and too white to be fully accepted as Native. Black Seminole families faced even harsher treatment: the U.S. demanded their return to slavery and pursued them relentlessly during the Second Seminole War (1835–1842).

​

Some intermarried families fled west with the Seminoles during removal, carrying their blended heritage to Indian Territory (present-day Oklahoma). Others retreated into the swamps and forests of central and southern Florida. Yet not all left. Many families with Muskogee, Seminole, and Scots-Irish ancestry remained quietly in the Panhandle, blending into the growing settler population. Outwardly, they lived as farmers, fishermen, and laborers; inwardly, they preserved stories of Creek or Seminole grandmothers, of Scots-Irish traders who became kin, and of the wars that reshaped their world.

​

The Setting of The Film The Paper Bear

​

Descendants of these intermarried families still live in the Panhandle. Many identify simply as local Floridians with deep roots, while others maintain oral traditions of Creek, Seminole, or Black Seminole ancestry. They are living reminders that the Panhandle’s history was never just Native versus white or enslaved versus free. It was a complex frontier of intermarriage, alliance, and survival.  Where Spain saw strength, the United States saw danger, and families themselves endured in the borderlands of identity.

​

In the film The Paper Bear, a father leads his son into the wilds of the Florida Panhandle, tracing not only the tracks of rarely seen animals but also the roots of their own ancestry. Descended from one of the region’s intermarried Scots-Irish and Seminole-Creek families, the father carries this history with care. He shares stories and accounts of their ancestors, passed down over generations, yet he reveals only fragments, allowing the boy to discover the full meaning for himself. His lessons of nature, of memory, of heritage form a subtle bridge across generations, turning their journey into a meditation on discovery, inheritance, and the quiet work of family healing.

​

​

​